All Woman
  • Home
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
    • Home
    • Relationships
    • Features
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Health & Fitness
    • Your Rights
    • Parenting
    • Advice
Bad boys
Advice, All Woman
 on February 21, 2022

Bad boys

Christopher Brodber 

WELL, you like many, might think no proper-thinking woman would knowingly date a bad man. However, some women do, and love them dearly. I was a bit stunned watching the video that circulated on social media where a Jamaican woman ranted about only wanting to be with a “gunman”. And of course, there’s music that testifies to the delight that some women find in their bad men. I have only recently learnt of that song with the chorus praising the merits of the romantic gunman, and there’s an explanation to this situation, plausible or not. And yes, real consequences there are too.

I’d think a woman might fear getting caught up in the dangerous lifestyle of her beloved bad man. But this is Jamaica, where community dynamics can cause a plethora of what may be illogical choices. Perceived protection from larger, lawless environments can cause women to feel comfortable in the arms of very bad men. A bad man offers ‘protection’ for herself and her family. Are these women wrong to think like this? Some women have experienced brutality at the hands of members of their community, and they’ve found no help, or little help, from the law. They’ve seen fathers killed, daughters raped, sons forced into things that they’d not want to participate in. To these women a bad man might be a helpful hero. She may not label her guy as a ‘gunman’ or ‘bad-man’. She may never see him as a criminal, as the television news says he is. Instead she sees him as a protector and a provider. He is her security and she will do anything to support him.

I spoke with one such young lady. She had not sought to date or fall in love with a bad man, but she fell in love with one, finding out later that he was a well-known, feared gunman. Her comments, “He loved me. So many were afraid of him. He was a don and people were afraid of him. But I wasn’t.”

She continued, “Every night I have to listen to the news. I knew the day would come… And every night after the news I would call him to make sure he’s alive. He was very bright. He wanted to be a criminal lawyer, to defend poor people.” The end of her story, thing that she feared was indeed the closure to their romance — he was slain by the police.

It is fair to think that, like any other woman, a woman in this situation would much prefer to live with security of another kind, protected by the law. They’d not have to worry about doors being kicked in by cops, or by other criminals, but this is their reality. Dating a ‘Shotta-type’ is the answer to tough community dynamics for some well-meaning women. But how quickly a collective in Jamaica can condemn women like that, when we see them on the news screaming in defence of their men who the police have captured or cut down. Many criticise them, not having a clue or genuine care about the conditions they’ve come up under. Conditions create conditions — and often critics have never experienced the conditions of those they criticise. The bad man boyfriend ‘locks-off the lane’ from drive-bys and other incursions by gunmen, and he’s admired by some for it.

However, the story of the lady I spoke with is very often the end story of most women who choose to love bad men. The romance typically ends with tragedy and anguish. Attraction to the bad guy, for whatever reason, never seems to end with, “They lived happily ever after”.

Rev Christopher Brodber is a counsellor and minister of religion. E-mail him at chrisbrodber@yahoo.com.

{"website":"website"}{"allwoman":"All Woman"}
0 Comments · Make a comment

HOUSE RULES

  1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper; email addresses will not be published.
  2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
  3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
  4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
  5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
  6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
  7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
ALSO ON ALL WOMAN
Speaking with courage
All Woman, Features
Speaking with courage
Krystal Tomlinson Carter shares how women can find their voice
March 23, 2026
IN many professional and personal spaces, women often hold thoughtful ideas but hesitate to express them. For some, it is uncertainty about whether th...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
No romance, no spice
Advice, All Woman
No romance, no spice
Rev Christopher Brodber 
March 23, 2026
COUNSELLOR, My wife and I have been married eight years, and we have two children. Before the children everything was spicy and regular, but nowadays ...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Babymother says I’m not the father
All Woman, Features, Your Rights
Babymother says I’m not the father
Margarette Macaulay 
March 23, 2026
DEAR MRS MACAULAY, My babymother registered our son in basic school under her name, and I only found out when I went to collect his report recently. W...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
5 downsides to staying with someone who constantly puts you down
All Woman, Features, Relationships
5 downsides to staying with someone who constantly puts you down
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
March 23, 2026
LET'S talk honestly, heart to heart, not about physical abuse, not about dramatic betrayals, but about something far more subtle, far more common, and...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
FROM THE GROUND UP
All Woman, Features
FROM THE GROUND UP
Gabrielle Gilpin-Hudson is rewriting real estate leadership in Jamaica
March 16, 2026
AT 32 years old, Gabrielle Gilpin-Hudson has shattered a 60-year record to become the youngest president in the history of the Realtors Association of...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
5 reasons why good women choose messy men
All Woman, Features, Relationships
5 reasons why good women choose messy men
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
March 16, 2026
LET’S have an honest, woman-to-woman conversation. Have you ever looked back at a relationship and asked yourself, “What was I thinking?” Have you eve...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
What happens to child custody if I die?
All Woman, Features, Your Rights
What happens to child custody if I die?
Margarette Macaulay 
March 16, 2026
DEAR MRS MACAULAY, I have full legal custody of my two children, and their father has visitation. He has never been a solid influence in their lives, ...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Unfit to be tied
Advice, All Woman, Features
Unfit to be tied
Christopher Brodber 
March 16, 2026
COUNSELLOR, Three years ago I manifested the man I wanted, and even dabbled in some spiritualist stuff to ensure that he was mine, and it worked. It w...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
❮ ❯
Scroll
Polls
Speaking with courage
All Woman, ...
Speaking with courage
Krystal Tomlinson Carter shares how women can find their voice
March 23, 2026
IN many professional and personal spaces, women often hold thoughtful ideas but hesitate to express them. For some, it is uncertainty about whether th...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
No romance, no spice
Advice, ...
No romance, no spice
Rev Christopher Brodber 
March 23, 2026
COUNSELLOR, My wife and I have been married eight years, and we have two children. Before the children everything was spicy and regular, but nowadays ...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Babymother says I’m not the father
All Woman, ...
Babymother says I’m not the father
Margarette Macaulay 
March 23, 2026
DEAR MRS MACAULAY, My babymother registered our son in basic school under her name, and I only found out when I went to collect his report recently. W...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
5 downsides to staying with someone who constantly puts you down
All Woman, ...
5 downsides to staying with someone who constantly puts you down
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
March 23, 2026
LET'S talk honestly, heart to heart, not about physical abuse, not about dramatic betrayals, but about something far more subtle, far more common, and...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
FROM THE GROUND UP
All Woman, ...
FROM THE GROUND UP
Gabrielle Gilpin-Hudson is rewriting real estate leadership in Jamaica
March 16, 2026
AT 32 years old, Gabrielle Gilpin-Hudson has shattered a 60-year record to become the youngest president in the history of the Realtors Association of...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Archives
Polls
Recent Posts
Speaking with courage
All Woman, ...
Speaking with courage
Krystal Tomlinson Carter shares how women can find their voice
March 23, 2026
IN many professional and personal spaces, women often hold thoughtful ideas but hesitate to express them. For some, it is uncertainty about whether th...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
No romance, no spice
Advice, ...
No romance, no spice
Rev Christopher Brodber 
March 23, 2026
COUNSELLOR, My wife and I have been married eight years, and we have two children. Before the children everything was spicy and regular, but nowadays ...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Babymother says I’m not the father
All Woman, ...
Babymother says I’m not the father
Margarette Macaulay 
March 23, 2026
DEAR MRS MACAULAY, My babymother registered our son in basic school under her name, and I only found out when I went to collect his report recently. W...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
5 downsides to staying with someone who constantly puts you down
All Woman, ...
5 downsides to staying with someone who constantly puts you down
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
March 23, 2026
LET'S talk honestly, heart to heart, not about physical abuse, not about dramatic betrayals, but about something far more subtle, far more common, and...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
FROM THE GROUND UP
All Woman, ...
FROM THE GROUND UP
Gabrielle Gilpin-Hudson is rewriting real estate leadership in Jamaica
March 16, 2026
AT 32 years old, Gabrielle Gilpin-Hudson has shattered a 60-year record to become the youngest president in the history of the Realtors Association of...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Archives
All Woman
Jamaica Health, Beauty, Weddings &` Motherhood Stories for the Jamaican Woman.
Sections
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
Jamaica Observer, © All Rights Reserved