All Woman
  • Home
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
    • Home
    • Relationships
    • Features
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Health & Fitness
    • Your Rights
    • Parenting
    • Advice
Surrogate mom now wants access
.
All Woman, Features, Your Rights
 on February 9, 2026

Surrogate mom now wants access

Margarette Macaulay 

Dear Mrs Macaulay,

My husband and I had fertility issues some years ago, and because we couldn’t afford fertility treatments, I allowed him to be with a family friend for the sole purpose of having a child. She had six other children, and so she agreed to relinquish her rights to the child (not legally) and allow us to raise him. She migrated without her other children, and my husband and I raised our child for nine years, with no contact from the mom. The biological mom and my husband are on the birth certificate, but I am on all his school and other documents as his mother. This woman has since resurfaced and says she wants access to her child, as her conscience can’t allow her to ignore the fact that she has a child out there. Our son doesn’t know any of the details of his birth and thinks I am his mom. How can we handle this legally? We are willing to allow her some access as just a family friend, but we don’t want him knowing that this is his biological mother.

 

Oh dear, this is why I keep advising people not to do anything or take any steps which touch on legal rights without consulting an attorney about the existing and possible future consequences.

You see, there is no law in Jamaica as yet which deals with or regulates surrogacy arrangements. Even if you have a written agreement, it will not be recognised as being legally binding. In other words, when you enter into a surrogacy arrangement, you are merely taking your chance that the surrogate will honour the agreement.

It is good that your husband is registered on the child’s birth certificate. He has all the legal rights of a father under the law. You, however, do not, and even the fact that you are in all the school and other documents as his mother does not make you a person with legal rights. You are really like a guardian mother — the person who takes care of him and who the father permits to do so. You have no legal right or recognition as his mother.

The surrogate mother is his legal and registered mother and she retains all the attendant rights of a mother, including access/visitation rights until you and your husband take steps to obtain orders for legal custody and care and control by an application to the court, or you apply to adopt the child.

I seriously advise you that to enter another non-binding arrangement with the surrogate mother should only be a temporary measure, because she could decide to be more intrusive in the child’s life, whatever your new arrangements are. She has proved to be quite selfish in thinking only about herself now after nine years, and not about the effect her appearance would have on the child. She is at minimum irresponsible and reckless, without any consideration of what her actions would cause to others.

You should, therefore, apply for legal custody, care, and control of the child now! You and your husband should explain to the mother that this would be in the best interests of the child, so that he is not traumatised by her sudden appearance in his life as a “mother“ when he already, for nine years, has only known you as his mother. The application for legal custody and care and control would name your husband and the surrogate mother as the respondents, and so she must be served and appear at the hearing. Her demand for access should also be put before the court, which has to decide the application and make orders which are in the best interests of your son, and she shall be legally bound by the orders made by the court. Any breach by her would be in contempt.

This, to me, is the best way to safeguard your son. The surrogate mother would still be registered as his mother on the birth certificate, but her rights to custody, care, and control would legally be yours, and her rights to access would only be as ordered by the court.

You and your husband should also, after the above, discuss the issue of you applying to adopt your son. This, if the surrogate agrees, would terminate all her rights and obligations to the child and you would have your name replace hers in the birth registration records. Or you can be satisfied with obtaining the court orders granting you legal custody, care, and control of the child; and access, if the court agrees and makes specific orders as to its frequency, its length, the place, and how she should present herself to the child so as not to identify herself in any way as his biological mother by any thing she says to him.

I do not in any way or form agree with you and your husband’s willingness to allow her some access as just a family friend, since you do not want your son to know that she is his biological mother. How do you think you can curtail her words without the weight of a legal order, which you should and could have obtained anytime during the nine years she was away and completely silent? This fact can be very effectively used in the course of your application for custody, care, and control and would assure your success in obtaining your order.

You and your husband cannot seriously mean to rely on this woman to keep to any agreed access. Do you seriously want to put your hands in the fire with this woman twice and gamble with your son’s sense of security and trust in his parents? So please retain an attorney-at- law who has a family practice/experience and put all the facts to him or her. Please act on the matter legally through court orders and so secure your child’s future factually, emotionally, and psychologically as best you can and do not leave it in the hands of an untrustworthy person, who was your erstwhile family friend. It is up to you to act properly and legally this time before the worst happens.

All the very best to you, your husband, and son.

 

Margarette May Macaulay is an attorney-at-law, Supreme Court mediator, notary public, and women’s and children’s rights advocate. Send questions via e-mail to allwoman@jamaicaobserver.com; or write to All Woman, 40-42 1/2 Beechwood Avenue, Kingston 5. All responses are published. Mrs Macaulay cannot provide private, personal responses.

{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman"}
0 Comments · Make a comment

HOUSE RULES

  1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper; email addresses will not be published.
  2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
  3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
  4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
  5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
  6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
  7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
ALSO ON ALL WOMAN
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
All Woman, Features
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
November 9, 2026
THE barriers women face in pursuing leadership positions are well documented, but Dr Luz Longsworth believes there is more to professional advancement...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
How to move on when someone has hurt you
All Woman, Features, Relationships
How to move on when someone has hurt you
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
November 9, 2026
NOW, this is something that can keep you emotionally stuck, waiting for an apology that never comes. Perhaps your partner disappointed you when you ne...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
He’s resisting marriage
Advice, All Woman, Features
He’s resisting marriage
Rev Christopher Brodber 
November 9, 2026
Counsellor, I’ve been with my man for several years, and every time I bring up marriage, I hear the same excuses: we’re not financially ready, we need...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Dr Rosemarie Lewis launches Total Healthcare Services & Wellness
All Woman, Features
Dr Rosemarie Lewis launches Total Healthcare Services & Wellness
Howard Campbell 
November 9, 2026
A healthcare professional for 40 years, Dr Rosemarie Lewis has worked with some of the leading medical providers in South Florida. One of her ambition...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Leadership based on capability
All Woman, Career & Education, Career & Education Front Page
Leadership based on capability
Women at the helm of Mayberry's governance and operations backbone
November 8, 2026
MAYBERRY Investments Limited (MIL) has reinforced the leadership behind its control environment and operational infrastructure, with three women now l...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
From pain to purpose: Onique Bolton’s journey of resilience and empowerment
All Woman, Features
From pain to purpose: Onique Bolton’s journey of resilience and empowerment
November 2, 2026
FOR Onique Bolton, the journey to becoming a nail educator and entrepreneur was never simply about mastering a beauty technique. It was about survival...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Forgiven, but not forgotten
Advice, All Woman, Features
Forgiven, but not forgotten
Rev Christopher Brodber 
November 2, 2026
Counsellor, My fiancé cheated on me, and even though I decided to forgive him, I still find myself checking his phone, questioning his whereabouts, an...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Spousal support options after decades of marriage
All Woman, Features, Your Rights
Spousal support options after decades of marriage
Margarette Macaulay 
November 2, 2026
Dear Mrs Macaulay, I have been married to a man for 27 years. I filed for divorce in 2024. The filling is still in court. What are my options with reg...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
❮ ❯
Scroll
Polls
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
All Woman, ...
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
November 9, 2026
THE barriers women face in pursuing leadership positions are well documented, but Dr Luz Longsworth believes there is more to professional advancement...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
How to move on when someone has hurt you
All Woman, ...
How to move on when someone has hurt you
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
November 9, 2026
NOW, this is something that can keep you emotionally stuck, waiting for an apology that never comes. Perhaps your partner disappointed you when you ne...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
He’s resisting marriage
Advice, ...
He’s resisting marriage
Rev Christopher Brodber 
November 9, 2026
Counsellor, I’ve been with my man for several years, and every time I bring up marriage, I hear the same excuses: we’re not financially ready, we need...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Dr Rosemarie Lewis launches Total Healthcare Services & Wellness
All Woman, ...
Dr Rosemarie Lewis launches Total Healthcare Services & Wellness
Howard Campbell 
November 9, 2026
A healthcare professional for 40 years, Dr Rosemarie Lewis has worked with some of the leading medical providers in South Florida. One of her ambition...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Leadership based on capability
All Woman, ...
Leadership based on capability
Women at the helm of Mayberry's governance and operations backbone
November 8, 2026
MAYBERRY Investments Limited (MIL) has reinforced the leadership behind its control environment and operational infrastructure, with three women now l...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Archives
Polls
Recent Posts
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
All Woman, ...
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
November 9, 2026
THE barriers women face in pursuing leadership positions are well documented, but Dr Luz Longsworth believes there is more to professional advancement...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
How to move on when someone has hurt you
All Woman, ...
How to move on when someone has hurt you
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
November 9, 2026
NOW, this is something that can keep you emotionally stuck, waiting for an apology that never comes. Perhaps your partner disappointed you when you ne...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
He’s resisting marriage
Advice, ...
He’s resisting marriage
Rev Christopher Brodber 
November 9, 2026
Counsellor, I’ve been with my man for several years, and every time I bring up marriage, I hear the same excuses: we’re not financially ready, we need...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Dr Rosemarie Lewis launches Total Healthcare Services & Wellness
All Woman, ...
Dr Rosemarie Lewis launches Total Healthcare Services & Wellness
Howard Campbell 
November 9, 2026
A healthcare professional for 40 years, Dr Rosemarie Lewis has worked with some of the leading medical providers in South Florida. One of her ambition...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Leadership based on capability
All Woman, ...
Leadership based on capability
Women at the helm of Mayberry's governance and operations backbone
November 8, 2026
MAYBERRY Investments Limited (MIL) has reinforced the leadership behind its control environment and operational infrastructure, with three women now l...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Archives
All Woman
Jamaica Health, Beauty, Weddings &` Motherhood Stories for the Jamaican Woman.
Sections
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
Jamaica Observer, © All Rights Reserved