All Woman
  • Home
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
    • Home
    • Relationships
    • Features
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Health & Fitness
    • Your Rights
    • Parenting
    • Advice
A puzzling threesome
.
Advice, All Woman, Features
 on November 16, 2026

A puzzling threesome

Rev Christopher Brodber 

Counsellor,

My girlfriend keeps telling me that I’m the guy she wants to spend the rest of her life with, but her relationship with her daughter’s father is becoming a serious problem in our relationship. They have constant phone calls, late-night conversations, unnecessary arguments, and situations where I feel like I’m competing with a man from her past. Whenever I complain, I’m accused of being jealous or insecure and reminded that they have a child together and have to co-parent. I understand that co-parenting is important, but where exactly should the boundaries be? Am I wrong for demanding respect in my relationship, or did I unknowingly sign up for a love triangle?

 

Your girlfriend is constantly communicating with her child’s father, and it’s making you uncomfortable. Understood. You are not being unreasonable for expressing concern about her relationship with him. You are wise to consider the issue carefully. Remember, you are simply dating/courting your girlfriend at this point. This is where you assess everything. Now is when you both weigh the issue of character, commitment, comfort, and you determine critical boundaries. An important question to answer, though, is whether their communication is genuinely about co-parenting, or if there is indeed an element of emotional entanglement.

Your concerns are relevant. And you aren’t wrong about desiring to feel respected. Particularly since men who are dating seem to be looking for “supportive” women: women who respect and support their dreams and goals. So loyalty is a big deal. Women, in essence, are looking for security: men who make them feel particularly safe. Stability is a big deal. You are evaluating if she really “has your back”.

Now, she is correct: they will have to co-parent, and he will apparently be around for a while. The child’s well-being is important. There’s essentially nothing wrong with that; in fact, it is commendable for the child’s father to be actively involved in the child’s life. More men should be actively involved with their children when their romantic relationships end. But if their situation is an unfolding “drama” for you, you get to freely determine what your tolerance level is. No one can “sign” you up. You get to choose.

REV CHRIS BRODBER.

REV CHRIS BRODBER.

Having a girlfriend is a beautiful thing. And romance is a spice of life. But peace, that’s a premium. And your entire future rests on your mental and emotional health. So evaluate and manage things well. Jeopardising each other’s peace or mental health isn’t an option. Your task now is to communicate your feelings effectively and to give her ample opportunity to clearly articulate her position. Work diligently at finding common ground. After a few rounds of deep discussion, you should hope to determine what works for both of you and what doesn’t.

The boundaries I would suggest:

•Communication should remain appropriately focused on the child’s welfare and their parenting responsibilities.

•Socialising or spending extended periods with him, either on the phone or in person, should be transparent and mutually understood.

.

•Neither of you should discuss private affairs with any former romantic partner without permission.

•Both of you should respect each other’s emotional needs.

Whatever the boundaries are, they should be mutually agreed. And they should facilitate mutual trust. Boundaries aren’t about controlling anyone else’s relationships; they are about establishing the conditions under which you can participate in a healthy relationship. Remember, all you are doing at this point in the relationship is evaluating things. You’re evaluating the viability of the relationship, based on the agreed boundaries, agreed plans, and your needs and goals.

Healthy romantic relationships depend on the establishment and maintenance of trust. There’s not much to work with for either of you if your trust is compromised. Be honest with yourself, too, though. Consider if it’s remotely possible that you’re uncomfortable because your girlfriend has to maintain a relationship with another man. Be sincere and objective with your evaluation, and give room if balance is needed.

 

Get on The Counsellor’s Couch with Rev Christopher Brodber, who is a counsellor and minister of religion. E-mail questions to allwoman@jamaicaobserver.com.

{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
0 Comments · Make a comment

HOUSE RULES

  1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper; email addresses will not be published.
  2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
  3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
  4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
  5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
  6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
  7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
ALSO ON ALL WOMAN
Latoya Whitton: From shrinking to shining
All Woman, Features
Latoya Whitton: From shrinking to shining
A journey of faith, resilience and rediscovery
November 16, 2026
For Latoya Hall Whitton, life has been a journey marked by pain, perseverance, faith, restoration and, ultimately, finding the courage to use her voic...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Mom wants more child support
All Woman, Features, Your Rights
Mom wants more child support
Margarette Macaulay 
November 16, 2026
Dear Mrs Macaulay, My child’s mother says she is taking me to court for maintenance, even though I visit and pay money to her regularly. She says what...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
A puzzling threesome
Advice, All Woman, Features
A puzzling threesome
Rev Christopher Brodber 
November 16, 2026
Counsellor, My girlfriend keeps telling me that I’m the guy she wants to spend the rest of her life with, but her relationship with her daughter’s fat...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
How much should you tell your partner about your past?
All Woman, Relationships
How much should you tell your partner about your past?
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
November 16, 2026
PICTURE this. You are in a relationship with someone. You are happy and things are going well. Then the uncomfortable questions begin. How many people...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman"}
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
All Woman, Features
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
November 9, 2026
THE barriers women face in pursuing leadership positions are well documented, but Dr Luz Longsworth believes there is more to professional advancement...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
How to move on when someone has hurt you
All Woman, Features, Relationships
How to move on when someone has hurt you
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
November 9, 2026
NOW, this is something that can keep you emotionally stuck, waiting for an apology that never comes. Perhaps your partner disappointed you when you ne...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
He’s resisting marriage
Advice, All Woman, Features
He’s resisting marriage
Rev Christopher Brodber 
November 9, 2026
Counsellor, I’ve been with my man for several years, and every time I bring up marriage, I hear the same excuses: we’re not financially ready, we need...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Dr Rosemarie Lewis launches Total Healthcare Services & Wellness
All Woman, Features
Dr Rosemarie Lewis launches Total Healthcare Services & Wellness
Howard Campbell 
November 9, 2026
A healthcare professional for 40 years, Dr Rosemarie Lewis has worked with some of the leading medical providers in South Florida. One of her ambition...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
❮ ❯
Scroll
Polls
Latoya Whitton: From shrinking to shining
All Woman, ...
Latoya Whitton: From shrinking to shining
A journey of faith, resilience and rediscovery
November 16, 2026
For Latoya Hall Whitton, life has been a journey marked by pain, perseverance, faith, restoration and, ultimately, finding the courage to use her voic...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Mom wants more child support
All Woman, ...
Mom wants more child support
Margarette Macaulay 
November 16, 2026
Dear Mrs Macaulay, My child’s mother says she is taking me to court for maintenance, even though I visit and pay money to her regularly. She says what...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
A puzzling threesome
Advice, ...
A puzzling threesome
Rev Christopher Brodber 
November 16, 2026
Counsellor, My girlfriend keeps telling me that I’m the guy she wants to spend the rest of her life with, but her relationship with her daughter’s fat...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
How much should you tell your partner about your past?
All Woman, ...
How much should you tell your partner about your past?
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
November 16, 2026
PICTURE this. You are in a relationship with someone. You are happy and things are going well. Then the uncomfortable questions begin. How many people...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman"}
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
All Woman, ...
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
November 9, 2026
THE barriers women face in pursuing leadership positions are well documented, but Dr Luz Longsworth believes there is more to professional advancement...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Archives
Polls
Recent Posts
Latoya Whitton: From shrinking to shining
All Woman, ...
Latoya Whitton: From shrinking to shining
A journey of faith, resilience and rediscovery
November 16, 2026
For Latoya Hall Whitton, life has been a journey marked by pain, perseverance, faith, restoration and, ultimately, finding the courage to use her voic...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Mom wants more child support
All Woman, ...
Mom wants more child support
Margarette Macaulay 
November 16, 2026
Dear Mrs Macaulay, My child’s mother says she is taking me to court for maintenance, even though I visit and pay money to her regularly. She says what...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
How much should you tell your partner about your past?
All Woman, ...
How much should you tell your partner about your past?
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
November 16, 2026
PICTURE this. You are in a relationship with someone. You are happy and things are going well. Then the uncomfortable questions begin. How many people...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman"}
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
All Woman, ...
Dr Luz Longsworth explores leadership’s hidden currents
November 9, 2026
THE barriers women face in pursuing leadership positions are well documented, but Dr Luz Longsworth believes there is more to professional advancement...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
How to move on when someone has hurt you
All Woman, ...
How to move on when someone has hurt you
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
November 9, 2026
NOW, this is something that can keep you emotionally stuck, waiting for an apology that never comes. Perhaps your partner disappointed you when you ne...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Archives
All Woman
Jamaica Health, Beauty, Weddings &` Motherhood Stories for the Jamaican Woman.
Sections
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
Jamaica Observer, © All Rights Reserved