Mom wants more child support
Dear Mrs Macaulay,
My child’s mother says she is taking me to court for maintenance, even though I visit and pay money to her regularly. She says what I give her isn’t enough, and says I can afford more. I currently give her $40,000 per month for our three year old, plus provide grocery items and pay for kindergarten. What is the likely outcome in court? Is there anything that I should counter sue for?
You are clearly a responsible father as you have been providing for your daughter’s maintenance despite your child’s mother’s threat to apply to the Family Court for an increase.
I shall answer the last request first as it is very important for you and your child. You must go to the court’s office and inform them that you wish to apply for an order for joint legal custody of your child and an order that your access to your child be made for specific days and times with increases as your daughter gets older, as presently the mother is exercising sole custody and care and control. Neither of you have legal custody of the child and you must have this done now. An order granting you both joint legal custody would mean that you both must make all developmental decisions relating to your daughter’s life, throughout the years of her minority. These include all decisions relating to her health, her receipt of medical service, choice of doctors, all educational matters, the school she attends and activities she participates in, her religious education and membership, any travelling especially out of the island, and in whose care she can be placed in. These are all important decisions relating to matters which can affect her proper and wholesome development.
The Children (Guardianship and Custody) Act gives both parents equal rights of custody of their children. You are entitled to have joint custody and you must apply for this as soon as possible. Also remember to apply for an order for your access to your child, and that it states your days and periods in clear and specific terms.
On the issue of maintenance, this is within the purview of the provisions of the Maintenance Act 2005 and its amendments in 2024. The Act imposes obligations on both parents for the maintenance of their children. It states that every parent has a legal obligation as far as the parent is capable of doing so, to maintain his or her unmarried child who is a minor, or who is physically or mentally ill or disabled.
As you can see the obligation rests on both mother and father. Therefore, the court has to, based on the evidence produced by the parties, divide the whole obligation between the parents based on their proven capabilities to provide support and make its order in monetary terms, and the periods of such payments and by what means and to which institution.
What can you do to defend yourself or how can you counter her application with yours? You must first get all your information ready of your income – gross and net; your necessary and current and future expenses; any other obligations you may have supporting any other family member; and your own personal living expenses. Do not forget to include all you currently provide for your daughter. Have it prepared in the form of a Statement of Account and have at hand any documents which can support or prove any of the entries. For instance, have some copies of your payslips, receipts, etc, available.
You must get the clerk to assist you to apply for the court to certify that the maintenance/support you now provide is sufficient or with whatever addition the judge considers reasonable for you to also provide.
Then you must also ask the clerk to assist you to apply for an order that the mother provides proof of her income and expenses also, and what she must also provide.
Though the Family Court was established to ensure access to any person who needs the intervention of the court for their rights to be upheld, without having to have the assistance of attorneys-at-law, it is sometimes advisable for an applicant to retain an attorney to represent them during the hearings in the court for many reasons of procedural practice and understanding of the applicable laws and rules. There is also the very important fact of having the necessary confidence to address the judge cogently and succinctly.
I feel very strongly that you should seriously consider retaining an attorney well versed in child law and Family Court procedures to represent you after you have had your applications prepared by the clerk and they have been filed and served. Your legal representative could always amend your applications if any matter is left out or not expansive enough.
The judge is to consider all the evidence of both parents’ incomes to determine their capacities and other matters stated in the Act before making the orders of your obligation and the mother’s based also on the paramount principle of the best interests of the child.
I trust that I have assisted you and that you will act to ensure that your child is properly provided for by both you and her mother. I applaud the fact that you have been a truly responsible father and I am certain that you shall continue to be so for your daughter. You must however make sure you act now, even if the mother does not file, to have the legal custody issue dealt with, so that orders will not be made without your evidential input and for more balanced orders to be made. Remember also, that if there are any change of circumstances in yours or your child’s life, that you can apply for the existing orders to be varied by the court.
I wish you and your daughter the very best.
Margarette May Macaulay is an attorney-at-law, Supreme Court mediator, notary public, and women’s and children’s rights advocate. Send questions via e-mail to allwoman@jamaicaobserver.com. All responses are published. Mrs Macaulay cannot provide personal responses.