Subscribe Login
Jamaica Observer
ePaper
The Edge 105 FM Radio Fyah 105 FM
Jamaica Observer
ePaper
The Edge 105 FM Radio Fyah 105 FM
    • Home
    • News
      • Latest News
      • Cartoon
      • International News
      • Central
      • North & East
      • Western
      • Environment
      • Health
      • #
    • Business
      • Business Bites
      • Social Love
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Basketball
      • Cricket
      • Horse Racing
      • World Champs
      • Commonwealth Games
      • FIFA World Cup
      • Olympics
      • #
    • Videos
    • Entertainment
      • Music
      • Movies
      • Art & Culture
      • Bookends
      • #
    • Lifestyle
      • Page2
      • Food
      • Tuesday Style
      • Food Awards
      • JOL Takes Style Out
      • Design Week JA
      • Black Friday
      • #
    • All Woman
      • Home
      • Relationships
      • Features
      • Fashion
      • Fitness
      • Rights
      • Parenting
      • Advice
      • #
    • Obits
    • Classifieds
      • Employment
      • Property
      • Motor Vehicles
      • Place an Ad
      • Obituaries
    • More
      • Games
      • Elections
      • Jobs & Careers
      • Study Centre
      • Jnr Study Centre
      • Letters
      • Columns
      • Advertorial
      • Editorial
      • Supplements
      • Webinars
    • Home
    • News
      • Latest News
      • Cartoon
      • International News
      • Central
      • North & East
      • Western
      • Environment
      • Health
      • #
    • Business
      • Business Bites
      • Social Love
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Basketball
      • Cricket
      • Horse Racing
      • World Champs
      • Commonwealth Games
      • FIFA World Cup
      • Olympics
      • #
    • Videos
    • Entertainment
      • Music
      • Movies
      • Art & Culture
      • Bookends
      • #
    • Lifestyle
      • Page2
      • Food
      • Tuesday Style
      • Food Awards
      • JOL Takes Style Out
      • Design Week JA
      • Black Friday
      • #
    • All Woman
      • Home
      • Relationships
      • Features
      • Fashion
      • Fitness
      • Rights
      • Parenting
      • Advice
      • #
    • Obits
    • Classifieds
      • Employment
      • Property
      • Motor Vehicles
      • Place an Ad
      • Obituaries
    • More
      • Games
      • Elections
      • Jobs & Careers
      • Study Centre
      • Jnr Study Centre
      • Letters
      • Columns
      • Advertorial
      • Editorial
      • Supplements
      • Webinars
  • Home
  • News
    • International News
  • Latest
  • Business
    • Business Bites
  • Cartoon
  • Games
  • Food Awards
  • Health
  • Entertainment
    • Bookends
  • Regional
  • Sports
    • Sports
    • World Cup
    • World Champs
    • Olympics
  • Videos
  • Career & Education
  • Classifieds
  • All Woman
  • Environment
  • Webinars
  • More
    • Football
    • Elections
    • Letters
    • Advertorial
    • Columns
    • Editorial
    • Supplements
  • Epaper
  • Design Week
St Elizabeth farmer who killed teen boys wins appeal
Deswick Williams
News
Alicia Dunkley-Willis | Senior Reporter  
April 12, 2022

St Elizabeth farmer who killed teen boys wins appeal

Offence moved from murder to manslaughter; prison time shortened

ALTON Baker, the man convicted for the slaying of two St Elizabeth students in January 2014, on Friday had his murder convictions set aside and substituted for manslaughter after the appeal court found that the trial judge had erred in failing to leave the issue of provocation to the jury, and as such deprived Baker “of the consideration of the lesser offence of manslaughter”.

The St Elizabeth man, who was in 2017 convicted on two counts of murder before Justice Martin Gayle, had been sentenced on both counts to life imprisonment at hard labour, with the stipulation that he should serve 30 years before becoming eligible for parole. Those sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

However, on Friday the court, which had reserved judgement in 2021 after hearing the appeal, ruled that the “convictions for murder on both counts of the indictment are quashed, judgements and verdicts of acquittal are entered and verdicts of guilty of manslaughter are substituted”.

It further ruled that the sentences of life imprisonment at hard labour with the stipulation that the appellant serves 30 years before becoming eligible for parole be set aside and sentences of 24 years’ imprisonment at hard labour for manslaughter substituted. The court further ruled that the sentences are to be viewed as having commenced on July 7, 2017 and are to run concurrently.

In the case, which captured national attention, the fathers of the 15-year-old teens Deswick Williams and Ashnell Coke on January 8 realised their sons were missing after neither were home at nightfall. A search party, which set out at 10 pm that night, led to a river where one of the boys would always fish and subsequently led to the discovery of their bodies.

The prosecution called eight witnesses, one of whom testified that she earlier that day heard the enraged farmer telling his grandmother that he “kill the two (expletive) boy dem who a nyam out mi grung [a colloquial word for farm]”.

According to the witnesss, the convicted man who she knew from birth then went on to say, “mi chop dem in ah dem head and a same so if me ketch Kenroy me a go push di machete through him neck… cause him drive down him car pon me and a same so if no pickney in deh me ah go kill di whole ah dem too.”

The court heard that the convicted man’s grandmother told him to calm down and offered him food, which he told her to put away until later.

The St Elizabeth police, based on information received in the hours following the gruesome discovery of the bodies, about 3:00 am, went to Baker’s house and took him into custody for questioning. The cops then returned to his home and seized a pair of water boots, items of clothing and three machetes that belonged to Baker before returning to the Siloah Police Station, where he was arrested on reasonable suspicion of murder.

During the trial Baker, in a brief unsworn statement from the dock, said that he did not commit the murders and he knew nothing about them. He also denied making the statements attributed to him.

Counsel for Baker, in filing the appeal on seven grounds, argued mainly that he was denied a fair trial because of various failures and/or errors on the trial judge’s part.

On the issue of whether the trial judge’s directions to the jury on how to treat the statement of the witness to his grandmother in respect of the murders was inadequate, the court on Friday said, “even in the face of the deficiencies in the trial judge’s directions, we cannot say that the jury would have arrived at any other conclusion…consequently, we are satisfied that the conviction is safe on this basis, and the appellant has not suffered any substantial miscarriage of justice. Accordingly, this ground fails”.

On Friday the court in handing down its ruling said all the grounds of appeal had failed except for ground 5, which held that the trial judge erred in failing to leave the lesser offence of manslaughter, on the basis of provocation, to the jury for their consideration.

“Under that ground, as indicated earlier, we found that the trial judge erred in failing to leave the issue of provocation to the jury, thereby depriving the appellant of the consideration of the lesser offence of manslaughter. However, having regard to the compelling evidence against the appellant that was presented at the trial, we are of the view that, in the interests of justice, the proper course to adopt is to substitute verdicts of guilty of manslaughter in place of the verdicts of guilty for murder. For that reason, it is necessary for us to revisit the sentences that the trial judge imposed,” the appeal court said.

“As indicated, we find that the appropriate sentence range in the circumstances of this case, which involves two victims, would be between 15 to 25 years. Being mindful of the overwhelming evidence against the appellant and the age and immaturity of the victims, we think an appropriate starting point within the range would be 19 years’ imprisonment,” the court said further.

The court, in making its decision, also considered several aggravating factors which included, among other things, the prevalence of these offences in Jamaica and the location of the injuries, which were to the back of the heads as well as the mitigating factors such as an antecedent report, which described Baker as hard-working and a psychiatric report that indicated that the appellant had been affected by his prolonged use of ganja.

It said while as a result of the mitigating factors, the sentences would be adjusted downwards, when the aggravating and mitigating factors are balanced, it still found that the aggravating factors far outweigh the mitigating factors in the present case and that sentences close to the top of the range would be appropriate.

“As a result, when the total offending is looked at, in the round, against the background of the personal circumstances of the appellant, we believe a sentence of 24 years’ imprisonment at hard labour on each count of the indictment would be appropriate,” it said.

Ashnell Coke

{"website":"website"}{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
img img
0 Comments · Make a comment

ALSO ON JAMAICA OBSERVER

Child’s body found in Trelawny; two injured by irate residents in mob attack
Latest News, News
Child’s body found in Trelawny; two injured by irate residents in mob attack
July 21, 2026
TRELAWNY, Jamaica — Police are now on a scene where the body of a child was found with her throat slashed in Tyre district near Troy in south Trelawny...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Toll from Venezuela double earthquakes reaches 5,346 killed
Latest News, Regional
Toll from Venezuela double earthquakes reaches 5,346 killed
July 21, 2026
CARACAS, Venezuela (AFP) — The death toll from the double earthquakes that struck Venezuela nearly a month ago has reached 5,346, according to the lat...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Jamaica Post being repositioned as Gov’t service centre
Latest News, News
Jamaica Post being repositioned as Gov’t service centre
July 21, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — With approximately 400 postal points islandwide,  Jamaica Post is being repositioned as a government service centre to improve acc...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Brent crude passes $92 a barrel, highest price since June amid US-Iran flare up
International News, Latest News
Brent crude passes $92 a barrel, highest price since June amid US-Iran flare up
July 21, 2026
HONG KONG, China (AFP) — Oil rose in Asian trade Wednesday, with Brent crude hitting its highest price in more than a month, as Iran targeted United S...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Jamaican civil society groups participate in capacity-building human rights workshop
Latest News, News
Jamaican civil society groups participate in capacity-building human rights workshop
July 21, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Jamaican civil society organisations are now better equipped to engage with international human rights processes following a Unite...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Section of Mineral Heights to Lionel Town main road collapses— NSWMA
Latest News, News
Section of Mineral Heights to Lionel Town main road collapses— NSWMA
July 21, 2026
CLARENDON, Jamaica — The National Works Agency (NWA) is advising motorists to exercise extreme caution at this time when using the main road from Mine...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
‘Pink Panther’ saxophonist Plas Johnson dies at 94
International News, Latest News
‘Pink Panther’ saxophonist Plas Johnson dies at 94
July 21, 2026
LOS ANGELES, United States (AFP) — Jazz musician Plas Johnson, whose silky tenor saxophone played the Grammy-winning "Pink Panther" theme song, died J...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
US readies new tariffs as Trump’s 10% global levy to expire
International News, Latest News
US readies new tariffs as Trump’s 10% global levy to expire
July 21, 2026
WASHINGTON, United States (AFP) — The United States is set to impose new tariffs that could hit dozens of countries soon, trade envoy Jamieson Greer s...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
❮ ❯

Polls

HOUSE RULES

  1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper; email addresses will not be published.
  2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
  3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
  4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
  5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
  6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
  7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

Recent Posts

Archives

Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Tweets

Polls

Recent Posts

Archives

Logo Jamaica Observer
Breaking news from the premier Jamaican newspaper, the Jamaica Observer. Follow Jamaican news online for free and stay informed on what's happening in the Caribbean
Featured Tags
  • Editorial
  • Columns
  • Health
  • Auto
  • Business
  • Letters
  • Page2
  • Football
Categories
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Page2
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Page2
Ads
img
Jamaica Observer, © All Rights Reserved
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • RSS Feeds
  • Feedback
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Code of Conduct